Rating Summary:
We upgrade our rating on CalBank Plc (“CAL”) from “HOLD” to “ACCUMULATE”, with fair value easing marginally to GHS 0.85 per share (vs GHS 0.86 prior estimate) against a current market price of GHS 0.73, implying a 16.4% upside. A slightly better-than-expected 9M2026 performance largely offset the impact of a higher risk-free rate of 13.79% (the average yield on the newly issued 7-year and 4-year bonds), leaving our fair value broadly unchanged. The upgrade is therefore driven mainly by a 7.6% decline in the market price since our 1H2026 earnings update, which has widened the upside. We maintain the use of this bond yield plus a 5.0% risk premium over the CAPM approach, as observed equity betas no longer hold up statistically. On the relative valuation side, a tighter peer group has sharpened our multi-factor P/B regression and brought it closer to market-implied pricing. CAL’s improved Capital Adequacy Ratio (CAR), following the recent capital injection, puts the bank on a firmer footing and points toward sustainable year-on-year profitability. Although the numbers support the positive earnings outlook, our optimism comes with caveats.
Two constraints still stand between CAL and genuine value creation:
Two constraints still stand between CAL and genuine value creation:
- Retained earnings remain negative, capping internal capital generation and keeping dividends off the table for now.
- Despite a significant year-on-year jump in the loan book, treasury securities still dominate the balance sheet, and lending needs to pick up meaningfully to unlock further value.
So, although earnings have improved, core lending still trails the bank’s treasury securities holdings, and this will weigh on the strength and sustainability of future earnings. We expect Earnings Per Share (EPS) to remain stretched because of the enlarged share base following the 4Q2025 capital raise as 9M2026 EPS fell 61.5% y/y to GHS 0.1062, from GHS 0.2757, despite the 50.6% rise in profit, and a dividend payout is highly unlikely over the next two to three years. Having steadied the ship, management’s tone on the bank’s near-term performance is positive, and we share management’s optimism. The bank has stabilised and is rebounding, but we believe it has yet to hit its stride. A full recovery will require pushing the envelope on the loan portfolio and sustaining growth in non-funded income. Ultimately, our fair value for CAL is largely unchanged, easing marginally to GHS 0.85 from GHS 0.86. The upgrade is driven mainly by the wider gap between our fair value and the market price.
